A horrible and mysterious murder: a Christmas tale pt 6

Londoners reading their local newspaper, the Standard, on Monday, 18 February, 1856, would have been brought up short by this headline, tucked away at the bottom of page three under the ship news:

Newspaper headline: Dreadful murder at IslingtonSome would have been shocked, perhaps afraid or angry. But others would’ve read on with the avidity that only a true-crime thrill could bring to the mid-Victorian mind.

Newspaper report of the 'Islington murder'Horrible and mysterious! A foreigner! Obscurity! Those of us who think our tabloids scrape the bottom of the barrel with their scandal stories today might be surprised to know that similar barrels have been scratched at for centuries.

You might have heard about the Penny Dreadfuls, popular cheap sheets telling supposedly true crime stories from the 1860s onwards. Their predecessors, the Penny Bloods, were perhaps based more on real violent crimes, and were guzzled by the thrill-seeking public. And nothing was as delicious as a murder, whether Maria Marten’s or the ones committed by Sweeney Todd.

The British Library describes it as ‘murder as entertainment’, and historian Rosalind Crone writes about ‘scaffold culture’ and the ‘cult of the murderer’.

Mrs Lovatt's pie shop (Sweeney Todd) #victorianmurder

Mrs Lovatt’s pie shop (Sweeney Todd)

And the so-called Islington murder was committed at the height of this bloodthirsty era.

The story in this (second) edition of the Standard is slightly different from later ones, so I’ll give you a quick summary, since this was all that was known (or at least all the journalists were able to get out of the police).

The servant girl said that, about 11 o’clock at night on Saturday, she was in bed and heard ‘considerable scuffling and noise in the house, followed by the sound of screaming, which she thought was caused by her mistress quarrelling with the supposed niece and locking her up in the cellar.’

She pretended to be asleep when her mistress came up to her bed and ‘press[ed] a hand over her face’.

Next morning ‘her suspicions were… redoubled’ when the ‘niece’ didn’t appear. That evening, she slipped out of the house and ‘bursting into tears related to her companion the above incidents’. This person – and who knows why she was conveniently on the street – advised her to go to the police, who investigated and found the murdered girl.

The report ends with the fact that the body was left in the cellar ‘awaiting a coroner’s inquest’ and that ‘the house [had] been taken possession of by the police’.

Later that day large crowds gathered at Clerkenwell Police Court to get a look at the two accused, and the story was fleshed (ouch) out a lot more, as you’ll read in the next #Victorianmurder post.

Which you won’t have to wait long for this time. I promise.

* Image credits:

Newspaper extracts: The British Library Board, via Findmypast
Penny blood illustration: The Mysteries of London, via bl.uk

Catch up with A Christmas tale:
Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 7 | Part 8 | Part 9 | Part 10 | Part 11

About rebelhand

A Rebel Hand is: about Nicholas Delaney, Irish rebel of 1798, transported as a convict to New South Wales, roadbuilder, innkeeper and farmer. My great-great-great grandfather. Other ancestors transported to Australia, like Sarah Marshall, John Simpson and James Thomas Richards, pop up as well. This blog's also about the historical background to their lives, in England, Ireland, and Australia. My respectable Welsh ancestors sometimes get a look in.
This entry was posted in Genealogy, London and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

31 Responses to A horrible and mysterious murder: a Christmas tale pt 6

  1. Pingback: Criminal Lives, 1780-1925 | A Rebel Hand

  2. Pingback: Celestina’s life in Millbank Prison: a Christmas tale pt 22 | A Rebel Hand

  3. Pingback: Five years of blogging | A Rebel Hand

  4. Pingback: Will Celestina hang? A Christmas tale pt 20 | A Rebel Hand

  5. Pingback: Broadside ballads about Celestina: a Christmas tale pt 19 | A Rebel Hand

  6. Pingback: Celestina’s trial – verdict and sentence: a Christmas tale pt 18 | A Rebel Hand

  7. Pingback: Celestina Sommer’s trial for murder: a Christmas tale pt 17 | A Rebel Hand

  8. Pingback: Celestina at the Old Bailey: a Christmas tale pt 16 | A Rebel Hand

  9. Pingback: Celestina in Newgate Prison: a Christmas tale pt 15 | A Rebel Hand

  10. Pingback: New evidence against Celestina: a Christmas tale pt 14 | A Rebel Hand

  11. Pingback: A mob at the inquest: a Christmas tale pt 13 | A Rebel Hand

  12. Pingback: The inquest in the pub: a Christmas tale pt 12 | A Rebel Hand

  13. Pingback: A Christmas bonus | A Rebel Hand

  14. Pingback: Another murder: a Christmas tale pt 11 | A Rebel Hand

  15. Pingback: A Christmas tale: part 1 | A Rebel Hand

  16. Pingback: A Christmas tale pt 2: The first Celestina | A Rebel Hand

  17. Pingback: A Christmas tale pt 3 – baby Celestina and the Harringtons | A Rebel Hand

  18. Pingback: A Christmas tale pt 4 – what next for Celestina Elizabeth? | A Rebel Hand

  19. Pingback: Christmas turns to Sommer: A Christmas tale pt 5 | A Rebel Hand

  20. Pingback: Julia Harrington’s evidence: a Christmas tale pt 10 | A Rebel Hand

  21. Pingback: Who killed Celestina? A Christmas tale pt 9 | A Rebel Hand

  22. Pingback: The murder of Celestina Christmas: a Christmas tale pt 8 | A Rebel Hand

  23. Pingback: The body in the cellar: a Christmas tale pt 7 | A Rebel Hand

  24. Anne says:

    oops for look read like!


  25. Anne says:

    You do look to keep us in suspense, don’t you 🙂


  26. cassmob says:

    But wait, there’s more….I’m getting more and more curious! Those Victorians were strange people weren’t they? Have you read the various books by Anne Perry which are crime novels around this period?


Leave a Reply to Anne Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s